
A charity approached us as it was facing a significant irrecoverable Land Tax (VAT) bill. This related to the purchase of some land where it was planning to build a number of facilities. Primarily for VAT exempt purposes, so any VAT paid would essentially be a cost.
Although the seller had said that VAT was payable because of an Option To Tax made in 2005, the charity had agreed to buy the land in the expectation that the VAT could be waived. However, its attempts at getting the seller to waive the VAT had failed.
We reviewed the position and agreed that the VAT couldn’t be waived for the reasons that the charity had thought. Although, there were alternative arguments that the Option to Tax the seller had made in 2005 should not now apply.
There were two sides to this argument; firstly, that the Option to Tax had never applied to the land, and secondly, even if it had, it could now be disapplied because the land was no longer within the curtilage of the building that had originally been opted.
Our arguments relied on the VAT legislation that was in place at the time the original Option to Tax was made in 2005, which has since change, but can still be relied on.
On the strength of our arguments, the seller agreed to seek a ruling from HMRC, which we are currently awaiting.
Next step, get in touch with your VAT queries by clicking here

